Is the regulation library a matter of the previous for law corporations?

When I became a lawyer much more than fifty percent a century back, the regulation library was, by any measure, the heart of my regulation company. It was in which lawyers went to do lawful research—any and all research. That intended that all the young attorneys ended up in the library at some point practically just about every working day. On celebration, all the firm’s associates were in the library at the exact same time. Many associates were being also regular guests.

The library was, in several respects, a pleasant location to commit time. Visually, it was undeniably eye-catching. The infinite shelves of uniformly sure volumes produced an captivating history. (Television and film producers must agree. To this day, you rarely see a shot of a lawyer’s office with out these kinds of volumes prominently on display.) All those volumes, with all that understanding, manufactured me come to feel serious—even crucial.

The presence of other legal professionals, primarily the ones near my age, was yet another attraction. We engaged in smaller talk, and we talked about the lawful concerns that had introduced us there. Wanting back again, I recognize that in our lawful investigation, we occasionally relied on these discussions a lot more than was warranted. I was frequently tempted to give pounds to a fellow associate’s impression of an issue—particularly if it coincided with my own—even although that associate knew no extra than I did about the issue (which may well be next to very little). Call it security (or at minimum comfort) in figures.


Norm Tabler.

In 1989, just after lots of many years in a 1913-classic bank creating, the organization moved into a new downtown office environment building of its possess structure. (I was exempt from shifting obligations simply because the go-in date coincided with my wedding day, but no, that is not why I selected that day.)

The architects commissioned by the agency specialized in space for specialist provider businesses, these types of as regulation and accounting firms. The style reflected a profound understanding of attorney egos, as demonstrated by the development of 16 corner workplaces on most floors.

How do you get 16 corner workplaces on a ground? Notches. Think of Utah, with its notch exactly where the northeast corner would if not be. That notch doubles the selection of corners on the northeast. Now, consider a Utah-type notch at just about every of the 4 corners of the constructing and, for very good measure, 1 additional notch somewhere alongside each and every of the 4 sides of the setting up. Voila! Sixteen lawyers on every flooring can brag of occupying the corner workplace. (In bragging, it was never ever a corner workplace it was constantly the corner place of work.)

But again to the library. The front of the prime flooring of the building was the firm’s key reception region, wherever the elevators deposited shoppers and other people. It was built and furnished to impress, with an ocean of marble flooring and equally impressive furnishings. The entire equilibrium of the major floor was devoted to the legislation library, which also occupied the corresponding room on the floor under.

The two flooring of the library were connected by an elaborate inside stairway, individual from the other stairways in the making. Any inside stairway would have consumed a substantial amount of money of house on each and every ground. But this wasn’t just any stairway. This stairway wound its way leisurely and impressively from 1 ground to the other, consuming what felt like acres of if not usable floor space.

The library was gorgeous, even lavish, with its grand stairway, soaring windows, endless rows of uniformly certain volumes, matching cherrywood bookcases, rolling ladders, tables, carrels and millwork. I shudder to consider how a lot of cherry trees were being sacrificed for these furnishings.

In the heady times, when we initially occupied the developing, we all but wept at the beauty of that library. But it was not just its beauty. With a monopoly on research assets, the library remained essential to our observe of regulation and consequently a everyday gathering put for our legal professionals.

We relied on that library, and we beloved it—for a time. Why only for a time? For the reason that the library grew to become an anachronism. Its utility dropped drastically, as legal professionals shifted from their reliance on books and loose-leaf providers to the internet—first applying desktop personal computers and then also employing laptops, and inevitably, they relied on pocket-sizing smartphones, as nicely.

Our beloved library grew to become a ghost town. We not often entered it. It took on the unfortunate aura that vacant, disused room constantly appears to be to undertake. In fact, we no for a longer period observed it as wonderful. How could one thing be attractive when looking at it produced you unfortunate?

30 yrs following relocating into the making, the firm commissioned a significant renovation of all its many floors. What was the fate of the library? The exact same as the fate of your family’s aged cathode-ray tube Tv in the tremendous walnut cupboard: abandonment. The company relinquished its rights to the top rated two flooring, such as the reception region and library, and expanded on to floors beneath its present room. Who took over individuals two floors? No just one. They continue to be vacant to this working day.

What does the firm’s new library search like? There isn’t one particular.

I overlook that library. I miss out on the strategy of the library as a central collecting area in a law business. Conducting exploration on the web is undeniably additional efficient than reliance on a roomful of guides and free-leaf volumes. But it’s also a more solitary, lonelier exercise. And it doesn’t assist produce and sustain a sense of group and a company culture the way that the library did.

But why pay attention to me? I’m so caught in the earlier that I however use a go well with and tie to the business office.


Norm Tabler is a retired lawyer in Indianapolis, where by his follow centered on wellbeing regulation. He serves on the editorial advisory boards of the ABA Well being Law Section’s The Health and fitness Lawyer the ABA Senior Legal professionals Division’s Voice of Encounter e-e-newsletter (for which he writes the column “Adventures in the Law”) and the Indiana Condition Bar Association’s Res Gestae (for which he writes the column “Annals of the Law”). He writes and information a monthly podcast, The Lighter Facet of Wellbeing Legislation, for the American Wellbeing Regulation Association’s Health and fitness Law Weekly.


ABAJournal.com is accepting queries for first, considerate, nonpromotional posts and commentary by unpaid contributors to operate in the Your Voice area. Aspects and submission suggestions are posted at “Your Submissions, Your Voice.”


This column displays the thoughts of the creator and not essentially the views of the ABA Journal—or the American Bar Association.